|
印度桥梁倒塌骗局 道路和桥梁倒塌 又找到了新工作
印度桥梁倒塌骗局:同样的承包商建造了糟糕的道路和桥梁,他们倒塌了,他们又找到了新工作
去印度 r/india•8个月前
https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/1o8wrdt/indias_bridge_collapse_scam_same_contractors/
过去 5 年里,我一直在研究印度的桥梁和道路倒塌情况,发现了一种令人不安的模式 - 这实际上是一个招标骗局,承包商建造廉价的优质基础设施,基础设施倒塌,然后他们获得新的合同来重建或从事其他项目。让我来分解一下。
问题的规模
2020年至2025年间,印度发生的桥梁倒塌数量惊人。联邦部长尼廷·加德卡里 (Nitin Gadkari) 报告称,五年来 NHAI 道路、桥梁和隧道发生了 55 起倒塌或损坏事件,其中 40 起是在施工期间,15 起是在已完成的项目中。 (https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/55-instances-of-collapse-damage-on-nhai-roads-bridges-tunnels-in-5yrs-gadkari-101753886591588.html)
但媒体报道显示,真实数字要高得多——短短四年内就发生了 170 起倒塌事故,202 人死亡,这表明存在严重的漏报情况。
(https://www.newslaundry.com/2025/07/29/4-years-170-collapses-202-deaths-whats-ailing-indias-bridges)
2020 年的一项研究发现,1977 年至 2017 年间,印度有 2,130 座桥梁倒塌。
近年来的重大倒塌事件
2025 年 7 月 9 日,古吉拉特邦巴罗达的甘比拉大桥垮塌,车辆坠入马希河,造成 22 人死亡。这座已有 40 年历史的桥梁多年来结构已经老化,但仍然可以使用。当地人报告说,当车辆经过时,它会发生危险的摇晃,但当局仍保持交通畅通。
2022 年 10 月 30 日莫尔比吊桥倒塌,造成 135 人死亡。调查发现电线断裂、焊接错误和翻新不当。承包商未经适当测试就用铝板替换了木板。
五年来,古吉拉特邦总共发生了 17 起结构性故障。
2024 年,比哈尔邦在短短 20 天内就有 12 座桥梁倒塌。
浦那附近的 Indrayani 河大桥于 2025 年 6 月 15 日倒塌,造成 4 人死亡、18 人受伤。更换补助金已于前一年获得批准,但工作订单在 18 个月后才下达。
现在真正令人不安的是承包商招标游戏
Ranjit Buildcon - 艾哈迈达巴德
Ranjit Buildcon 在艾哈迈达巴德建造了 Mumatpura 天桥,该立交桥于 2021 年 12 月 21 日倒塌。AUDA 暂停了该公司的业务,并提议取消其资格三年。但更关键的是,在两次浮动招标但没有投标人的情况下,AUDA 向同一家公司授予了完成倒塌桥梁的合同。尽管调查委员会甚至没有提交最终报告,但这个耗资 8.2 亿卢比的项目已被交还给 Ranjit Buildcon。
这是涉及 Ranjit Buildcon 的第三起事故 - 2007 年苏拉特的早期桥梁项目也发生了导致一人死亡的事故。 (https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ahmedabad/collapse-of-ahmedabad-flyover-third-incident-involving-same-company-7687752/)
尽管有这样的记录,该公司仍在继续处理巴罗达、拉杰果德、苏拉特市政机构和艾哈迈达巴德-甘地讷格尔地铁铁路的重大项目。媒体报道将 Ranjit Buildcon 描述为古吉拉特邦政府“最喜欢的承包商”。
SP Singla 建筑 - 比哈尔邦
SP Singla Construction 耗资 171 亿卢比在巴加尔布尔地区修建了横跨恒河的 Aguwani-Sultanganj 大桥。该桥曾两次倒塌,第一次是在 2022 年 4 月 30 日,第二次是在 2023 年 6 月 4 日。
比哈尔邦发布了一份说明原因的通知,询问为什么该公司不应被列入黑名单。但请注意这一点 - SP Singla Construction 在此期间继续在古吉拉特邦开展重大项目。 (https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/contractor-of-collapsed-bihar-bridge-building-two-in-gujarat/articleshow/100806076.cms)
该公司已经在阿萨姆邦建造了桥梁,比哈尔邦倒塌后,阿萨姆邦 CM 下令对其桥梁进行 IIT 检查,但该公司仍然活跃。
GPC 基础设施 - Palanpur
GPC基础设施公司在2016-17年被古吉拉特邦人民党政府列入黑名单,原因是他们修建的道路的三分之一在艾哈迈达巴德的季风期间被冲毁。尽管被列入黑名单,该公司仍于 2021 年获得了建造帕兰普尔大桥的合同。该桥于 2023 年 10 月 23 日倒塌,造成两人死亡。国大党领袖阿米特·查夫达 (Amit Chavda) 声称,GPC 基础设施在 2019 年大选前已向印度人民党的政党基金捐赠了约 1 千万卢比。 (https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ahmedabad/palanpur-bridge-collapse-firm-blacklisted-2016-17-gujarat-congress-leader-amit-chavda-8999131/)
奥雷瓦集团 - 莫尔比
这绝对是疯了。 Oreva 集团未经任何招标程序就获得了莫尔比大桥翻修合同。 Oreva 专门生产 CFL 灯泡、挂钟和电动自行车 - 他们在桥梁施工方面的经验为零。
一家孟买公司以 l 的价格竞标该合同。
ower price, but the district collector received a call to award it to Oreva despite their higher quote and lack of expertise. The Gujarat High Court even questioned why the operation and maintenance contract was given without floating a tender.
The company claimed they did "100% renovation in ₹2 crore" but didn't replace old cables and opened the bridge without a fitness certificate.大桥倒塌,造成 135 人死亡。
正如国大党领袖阿米特·查夫达 (Amit Chavda) 所说:“今天在古吉拉特邦,如果你想签订道路或桥梁合同,只要不向 Kamlam [印度人民党办公室] 发送佣金,就不会授予合同。”
为什么没有真正的责任
Bihar suspended 16 engineers after 12 bridges collapsed in 20 days. But the Supreme Court criticized the government for reinstating suspended officers after public attention shifted. (https://www.deccanherald.com/india/bihar/bihar-bridge-collapses-officers-suspended-then-brought-back-observes-sc-3473956)
这种暂停“很难像过去那样起到威慑作用。几周后,一旦媒体和公众注意力转移,这些暂停就会被撤销”。 Government sources admit such committees have never led to punishment of any official or contractor in the past. (https://latest.sundayguardianlive.com/news/bridge-collapse-in-bihar-exposes-commission-system)
Companies simply change names to bypass blacklisting. S N Bhobe & Associates 在天桥倒塌后被苏拉特市政公司列入黑名单,但一个月内,该公司被分拆为 TPF Engineering Private Limited,董事不变。 TPF 随后赢得了六份孟买合同。 (https://indianexpress.com/article/india/under-new-name-firm-blacklisted-in-surat-won-six-mumbai-contracts-5739402/)
尽管NHAI道路、桥梁和隧道发生了55起塌方事故,但只有两起事件导致了纪律处分——一名项目负责人被停职,另一名项目负责人被调职。就是这样。
The Morbi case with 135 deaths remains without charges filed two years later.
穆马特普拉案揭示了机制
Mumatpura 倒塌后,AUDA 两次进行招标,但没有投标人出面,因为招标条件要求新投标人对整座桥梁负责,同时只完成剩余的施工。 This makes re-awarding to the original contractor the "easy" option for officials. (https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/barred-firm-to-complete-collapsed-flyover/articleshow/95870630.cms)
Additionally, contractors maintain political connections through donations and commissions that protect them from blacklisting.这就形成了一个恶性循环:腐败的招标→由于佣金制度而导致施工不合格→倒闭→同一承包商获得重建合同→重复。
崩溃后会发生什么
Compensation is announced but often not fully paid. After the Gambhira Bridge collapse, Gujarat CM announced ₹4 lakh compensation for each deceased and ₹50,000 for the injured. (https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/gujarat-bridge-collapse-gambhira-bridge-vehicles-fell-one-after-another-fisherman-on-moments-after-bridge-broke-8848187)
对于莫尔比,古吉拉特邦高等法院命令 Oreva 向每位死者家属支付 100 万卢比的临时赔偿,向受伤者支付 20 万卢比的临时赔偿,但该公司甚至连临时金额的 50% 都难以支付。 (https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/deposited-50-of-interim-compensation-for-morbi-bridge-victims-oreva-in-hc-123032700588_1.html)
经过10年的发展,比哈尔邦终于推出了桥梁维护政策,要求各部门对所有6200座桥梁保留有详细检查记录的“健康卡”。 But this was only done after repeated collapses forced their hand.
底线
This is a full-blown infrastructure scam running across multiple states.由于政治关系、佣金制度和故意缺乏问责制,建造不合格桥梁的承包商在倒塌后获得了新的招标。数百人死亡,调查毫无进展,暂停被撤销,通过更改公司名称绕过黑名单,如此循环继续。
The system is designed to benefit contractors and politicians while putting public lives at risk.在真正执行黑名单、独立审计、刑事起诉和打破佣金制度之前,这种情况将会持续发生。
India's Bridge Collapse Scam: Same Contractors Build Bad Roads and Bridges, They Fall Down, and They Get New Jobs Again
The Scale of the Problem
Between 2020-2025, India has witnessed an alarming number of bridge collapses. Union Minister Nitin Gadkari reported 55 cases of collapses or damages on NHAI roads, bridges, and tunnels over five years - 40 during construction and 15 on completed projects. (https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/55-instances-of-collapse-damage-on-nhai-roads-bridges-tunnels-in-5yrs-gadkari-101753886591588.html)
But media reports suggest the real number is much higher - 170 collapses with 202 deaths over just four years, indicating massive underreporting.
(https://www.newslaundry.com/2025/07/29/4-years-170-collapses-202-deaths-whats-ailing-indias-bridges)
A 2020 study found that 2,130 bridges collapsed in India between 1977 and 2017.
Major Collapses in Recent Years
Gujarat's Gambhira Bridge in Vadodara collapsed on July 9, 2025, killing 22 people when vehicles plunged into the Mahi River. The 40-year-old bridge had shown structural decay for years, yet remained operational. Locals reported it shook dangerously when vehicles crossed, but authorities kept it open to traffic.
The Morbi Suspension Bridge collapse on October 30, 2022 killed 135 people. Investigation revealed broken wires, faulty welding, and improper renovation. The contractor replaced wooden planks with aluminum sheeting without proper testing.
Gujarat has witnessed 17 structural failures over five years total.
Bihar saw 12 bridges collapse within just 20 days in 2024.
The Indrayani River bridge near Pune collapsed on June 15, 2025, killing four people and injuring 18. Grants for replacement had been approved the previous year, but work orders were issued only after 18 months.
Now Here's Where It Gets Really Disturbing - The Contractor Tender Game
Ranjit Buildcon - Ahmedabad
Ranjit Buildcon built the Mumatpura flyover in Ahmedabad that collapsed on December 21, 2021. AUDA suspended the company and proposed debarring them for three years. But here's the kicker - after floating tenders twice with no bidders, AUDA gave the exact same company the contract to complete the collapsed bridge. The ₹82 crore project was handed back to Ranjit Buildcon despite the investigation committee not even submitting its final report.
This was the THIRD incident involving Ranjit Buildcon - earlier bridge projects in Surat in 2007 also witnessed accidents where one person died. (https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ahmedabad/collapse-of-ahmedabad-flyover-third-incident-involving-same-company-7687752/)
Despite this track record, the company continues handling major projects for Vadodara, Rajkot, Surat civic bodies, and the Ahmedabad-Gandhinagar Metro Rail. Media reports describe Ranjit Buildcon as Gujarat government's "favourite contractor".
SP Singla Construction - Bihar
SP Singla Construction built the Aguwani-Sultanganj bridge over the Ganga in Bhagalpur district at a ₹1,710 crore cost. The bridge collapsed TWICE - first on April 30, 2022, and again on June 4, 2023.
Bihar issued a show-cause notice asking why the company shouldn't be blacklisted. But get this - SP Singla Construction continued operating on major projects in Gujarat during this entire period. (https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/contractor-of-collapsed-bihar-bridge-building-two-in-gujarat/articleshow/100806076.cms)
The company had already built bridges in Assam, and after the Bihar collapse, Assam CM ordered IIT inspections of their bridges, but the company remained active.
GPC Infrastructure - Palanpur
GPC Infrastructure was blacklisted by the BJP government in Gujarat in 2016-17 after one-third of a road they built got washed away during monsoon in Ahmedabad. Despite being blacklisted, the same company got a contract in 2021 to build the Palanpur bridge. That bridge collapsed on October 23, 2023, killing two people. Congress leader Amit Chavda alleged that GPC Infrastructure had contributed approximately ₹1 crore to the BJP's party fund before the 2019 election. (https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ahmedabad/palanpur-bridge-collapse-firm-blacklisted-2016-17-gujarat-congress-leader-amit-chavda-8999131/)
Oreva Group - Morbi
This one is absolutely insane. The Oreva Group was given the Morbi bridge renovation contract without any tender process at all. Oreva specializes in CFL bulbs, wall clocks, and e-bikes - they had ZERO experience in bridge construction.
A Bombay firm had bid for the contract at a lower price, but the district collector received a call to award it to Oreva despite their higher quote and lack of expertise. The Gujarat High Court even questioned why the operation and maintenance contract was given without floating a tender.
The company claimed they did "100% renovation in ₹2 crore" but didn't replace old cables and opened the bridge without a fitness certificate. The bridge collapsed killing 135 people.
As Congress leader Amit Chavda stated: "Today in Gujarat, if you want to take up a contract for a road or bridge, as long as a commission is not sent to the Kamlam [BJP office], the contract is not awarded."
Why There's No Real Accountability
Bihar suspended 16 engineers after 12 bridges collapsed in 20 days. But the Supreme Court criticized the government for reinstating suspended officers after public attention shifted. (https://www.deccanherald.com/india/bihar/bihar-bridge-collapses-officers-suspended-then-brought-back-observes-sc-3473956)
Such suspensions "hardly act as a deterrent, as has been seen in the past. These suspensions are revoked after few weeks once media and public attention shifts." Government sources admit such committees have never led to punishment of any official or contractor in the past. (https://latest.sundayguardianlive.com/news/bridge-collapse-in-bihar-exposes-commission-system)
Companies simply change names to bypass blacklisting. S N Bhobe & Associates was blacklisted by Surat Municipal Corporation after a flyover collapse, but within a month, the firm was demerged into TPF Engineering Private Limited with the same directors. TPF then won six Mumbai contracts. (https://indianexpress.com/article/india/under-new-name-firm-blacklisted-in-surat-won-six-mumbai-contracts-5739402/)
Despite 55 cases of collapses on NHAI roads, bridges, and tunnels, only TWO incidents resulted in disciplinary action - one project director was suspended and another transferred. That's it.
The Morbi case with 135 deaths remains without charges filed two years later.
The Mumatpura Case Reveals the Mechanism
When AUDA floated tenders twice after the Mumatpura collapse, no bidders came forward because tender conditions required the new bidder to take responsibility for the entire bridge while only completing remaining construction. This makes re-awarding to the original contractor the "easy" option for officials. (https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/barred-firm-to-complete-collapsed-flyover/articleshow/95870630.cms)
Additionally, contractors maintain political connections through donations and commissions that protect them from blacklisting. This creates a vicious cycle: corrupt tender awards → substandard construction due to commission system → collapse → same contractors get rebuild contracts → repeat.
What Happens After Collapses
Compensation is announced but often not fully paid. After the Gambhira Bridge collapse, Gujarat CM announced ₹4 lakh compensation for each deceased and ₹50,000 for the injured. (https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/gujarat-bridge-collapse-gambhira-bridge-vehicles-fell-one-after-another-fisherman-on-moments-after-bridge-broke-8848187)
For Morbi, the Gujarat High Court ordered Oreva to pay ₹10 lakh interim compensation to each deceased's family and ₹2 lakh to the injured, but the company struggled to pay even 50% of the interim amount. (https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/deposited-50-of-interim-compensation-for-morbi-bridge-victims-oreva-in-hc-123032700588_1.html)
Bihar finally rolled out a bridge maintenance policy after 10 years in development, requiring departments to maintain "health cards" with detailed inspection records for all 6,200 bridges. But this was only done after repeated collapses forced their hand.
The Bottom Line
This is a full-blown infrastructure scam running across multiple states. The same contractors who build substandard bridges get fresh tenders after collapses because of political connections, commission systems, and deliberate lack of accountability. Hundreds have died, investigations go nowhere, suspensions are reversed, blacklisting is bypassed by changing company names, and the cycle continues.
The system is designed to benefit contractors and politicians while putting public lives at risk. Until there's genuine enforcement of blacklisting, independent audits, criminal prosecution, and breaking the commission system, this will keep happening.
法律申明|用户条约|隐私声明|手机版|小黑屋|联系我们|www.kwcg.ca
GMT-5, 2026-6-4 02:39 , Processed in 0.012819 second(s), 17 queries , Gzip On.
Powered by Discuz! X3.4
© 2001-2021 Comsenz Inc.